MLab

Capitalism is Dead. Long Live Capitalism.

Posted by Gary Hamel on September 21, 2010

I’m a capitalist by conviction and profession. I believe the best economic system is one that rewards entrepreneurship and risk-taking, maximizes customer choice, uses markets to allocate scarce resources and minimizes the regulatory burden on business. If there’s a better recipe for creating prosperity I haven’t seen it.

So why do fewer than four out of ten consumers in the developed world believe that large corporations make a “somewhat” or “generally” positive contribution to society? (This according to a 2007 study by McKinsey & Company.) Why is it that only 19% of Americans tell pollsters they have “quite a lot” or a “great deal” of confidence in big business? (In the 2010 Gallup survey, only Congress scored worse.) It seems that a majority of us expect big companies to behave badly—to ravish the environment, exploit employees and mislead customers. When it comes to feckless irresponsibility, big business seems to be in the same league as Tiger Woods and Lindsay Lohan.

Some blame Wall Street for this state of affairs. In March 2009, the Financial Times claimed that the “credit crisis had destroyed faith in the free market ideology that has dominated Western thinking for a decade.” Around the world, hyperventilating pundits and grandstanding politicians argued that a new model of capitalism was needed—one that would make executives even more accountable to legislators and bureaucrats. Statists spied in the calamity a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to enlarge their regulatory fiefdoms—and moved swiftly to do so.

While one should never underestimate the ability of risk-besotted financiers to wreak havoc, the real threat to capitalism isn’t unfettered financial cunning. It is, instead, the unwillingness of executives to confront the changing expectations of their stakeholders. In recent years, consumers and citizens have become increasingly disgruntled with the implicit contract that governs the rights and obligations of society’s most powerful economic actors—large corporations. To many, the bargain seems one-sided—it’s worked well for CEOs and shareholders, but not so well for everyone else.

You don’t have to read Adbusters to wonder whose interests big business really serves. When it comes to “free markets,” there’s plenty to be cynical about.

If individuals around the world have lost faith in business, it’s because business has, in many ways, abused that faith. In this sense, the threat to capitalism is both more prosaic and more profound than that posed by marauding bankers—more prosaic in that the danger comes not from the esoteric schemes of “rocket scientists” but from the slowly accreting frustrations and anxieties of “ordinary” folks; and more profound in that the problem is truly existential—it threatens to burden every large company with the sort of regulatory constraints that were once reserved for nuclear power plants. No amount of cuddly, “here’s how much we care” PR is going to avert this danger.

Some may bemoan the fact that capitalism (broadly defined) has no credible challengers, but it doesn’t. Like democracy, it’s the worst sort of system except for all the others—and that’s why each of us has a stake in making it better. If we fail to do so, the growing discontent with business will embolden all those who believe CEOs should answer first and last to civil servants—to those who are eager to replace invisible hand of the market with the iron hand of the state.

This is not an outcome most of us would welcome. While cinching the regulatory straitjacket even tighter would protect us from capitalism’s worst excesses, it would also rob us of its bounties. So we must hope that executives will face up to the fact that an irreversible revolution in expectations has occurred.

Millions of consumers and citizens are already convinced of a fact that many corporate chieftains are still reluctant to admit: the legacy model of economic production that has driven the “modern” economy over the last hundred years is on its last legs. Like a piece of clapped out engine, it’s held together with bailing wire and duct tape, frequently breaks down and befouls the air with noxious fumes.

While we’re grateful that someone invented this clattering, savage machine a century and more ago, we’ll also be happy when it’s finally carted off to the scrap yard and replaced with something a bit less menacing.

We know the future cannot be an extrapolation of the past. As the great grandchildren of the industrial revolution, we have learned, at last, that the heedless pursuit of more is unsustainable and, ultimately, unfulfilling. Our planet, our security, our sense of equanimity and our very souls demand something better, something different.

So we long for a kinder, gentler sort of capitalism—one that views us as more than mere “consumers,” one that understands the difference between maximizing consumption and maximizing happiness, one that doesn’t sacrifice the future for the present and regards our planet as sacred.

So what stands in the way of creating a conscientious, accountable and sustainable sort of capitalism—a system that in the long-term is actually habitable?

It is, I think, a matrix of deeply held beliefs about what business is for, whose interests it serves and how it creates value. Many of these beliefs are near canonical (at least among CEOs of a particular generation or ideological bent). They are also narcissistic and archaic. Among the most toxic . . .

1. The paramount objective of a business is to make money (rather than to enhance human well-being in economically efficient ways).

2. Corporate leaders can only be held accountable for the immediate effects of their actions (and not for the second and third order consequences of their single-minded pursuit of growth and profitability).

3. Executives should be evaluated and compensated on the basis of short-term earnings (rather than on the basis of long-term value creation, both financial and social).

4. The way to establish a business’ social credentials is through high-minded mission statements, green-tinged products and a fat CSR budget (rather than through an unshakeable and sacrificial commitment to doing the right thing).

5. The primary justification for “doing good” is that it helps a company to “do well.” (The implication: a company should do good when there’s an upside and something less when there’s not).

6. Customers care a lot more about value for money than they do about the values that were honored (or defiled) in the making and selling of a product.

7. A firm’s “customers” are the folks who buy its services (rather than all those whose lives are impacted by its actions).

8. It’s legitimate for a company to make money by exploiting customer ignorance, exaggerating product benefits and constraining customer choice.

9. Market power and political leverage are acceptable ways of countering a disruptive technology or thwarting an unconventional competitor.

10. Business is about advantage, focus, differentiation, superiority and excellence (and not about love, joy, honor, beauty and justice).

Perhaps these self-serving convictions were less objectionable 57 years ago when General Motors’ then–chairman, Charles Wilson, proclaimed that “what is good for GM is good for America.” But today, they are discordant and dangerous. It is no good pretending that perceptions haven’t changed or that capitalism’s critics are simply misguided. There is a growing consensus that rampant consumerism debases human values; that pell-mell growth imperils the planet; that unchecked corporate power subverts democracy; and that myopic, profit-besotted CEOs are as likely to destroy value as create it.

I am an ardent supporter of capitalism—but I also understand that while individuals have inalienable, God-given rights, corporations do not. Society can demand of corporations what it likes. That’s why self-serving beliefs are also, ultimately, self-limiting.

Of course, as consumers and citizens, we must be acknowledge that companies can’t remedy every social ill or deliver every social benefit. We must also face up to our own schizophrenia. We can’t expect companies to behave responsibly if we blithely abandon our own principles to save a buck.

As for executives: if you feel your industry is still too lightly regulated, if you secretly long for the regulatory fetters to be tightened even further, if you think that Sarbanes-Oxley, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, the Restoring American Financial Stability Act and Basel III don’t go far enough—then just keep on doing what you’re doing. If, on the other hand, you’ve had enough of sanctimonious politicians and meddling bureaucrats, then you must face up to a simple fact: In the years to come, a company will be able to preserve its freedoms only if it embraces a new and more enlightened view of its responsibilities. Many CEOs have already resigned themselves to this new reality, and a handful have eagerly welcomed it. There are others, though, who still cling to the belief that a company is first and foremost an economic entity rather than a social one. Sooner or later, these holdouts will discover that they face the same hard choice that confronts every teenager—drive responsibly or lose your license. For the sake of capitalism, let’s hope it’s sooner.

So then, dear reader, two questions: Are there other beliefs you belief represent a threat to capitalism? And more generally, what do you think needs to be done to rehabilitate capitalism’s tarnished reputation?

And finally, a really important recommendation. If you’re eager to dig deeper into these issues, pre-order Umair Haque’s new book, “The New Capitalist Manifesto: Building a Disruptively Better Business,” to which I wrote a short foreword. Umair, who writes with uncommon wit and passion, draws a host of essential lessons from companies that have already embraced the challenge of reinventing capitalism. The New Capitalist Manifesto will be launched in January, and I expect it to become one of the most talked about books of 2011.

Comments

Reply to comment | MLab

Fantastic posts. Thanks.

Check out my homepage - ランバン 香水

Reply to comment | MLab

Superb material, Cheers!

Here is my site; ケイトスペード バッグ 人気

Reply to comment | MLab

Nicely put, With thanks!

Take a look at my blog; ヴィヴィアンウエストウッド ピアス 新作

Reply to comment | MLab

This is nicely put! !

my web blog ナイキ バッシュ ハイパーダンク

Reply to comment | MLab

Fantastic material Cheers!

Here is my website - グッチ 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Fine content Kudos.

Check out my web blog; Kate Spade 通販

Reply to comment | MLab

Factor clearly regarded.!

my web blog; ガガミラノ

Reply to comment | MLab

Useful information Thank you!

My web page; ジミーチュウ サンダル メンズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Well voiced truly! !

my page - コンバース スリッポン

Reply to comment | MLab

Fine facts Kudos!

my blog post :: ジミーチュウ 靴

Reply to comment | MLab

Beneficial information Many thanks.

my web-site ... レイバン サングラス 店舗

Reply to comment | MLab

Nicely put, Thank you.

My web page ボッテガヴェネタ 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Lovely facts, With thanks!

My weblog ... トリーバーチ サングラス

Reply to comment | MLab

Many thanks. An abundance of posts.

my website :: ガガミラノ時計 激安

Reply to comment | MLab

Amazing forum posts Thanks.

My web site トムフォード サングラス 店舗

Reply to comment | MLab

Superb postings, Thanks.

Visit my blog post ガガミラノ 人気

Reply to comment | MLab

You said it nicely.!

Look at my web blog ... ブルガリ 香水 プールオ

Reply to comment | MLab

This is nicely put! !

Feel free to visit my web site - プラダ 財布 公式

Reply to comment | MLab

Cheers, I enjoy this!

My homepage ジミーチュウ 靴

Reply to comment | MLab

Thanks. Very good information!

Here is my weblog: ジミーチュウ 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

You explained this perfectly!

Feel free to visit my web site ... クロムハーツ メガネ

Reply to comment | MLab

Helpful data Cheers!

Look at my web blog; フルラ 長財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Regards, Numerous posts.

My blog ... katespade 時計 リボン

Reply to comment | MLab

With thanks. Helpful information.

Here is my site :: ルイヴィトン 財布 新作 2014

Reply to comment | MLab

You've made your position very clearly.!

my web site クロムハーツ リング 新作

Reply to comment | MLab

You said it perfectly..

My site ... MCM 財布 ファスナー

Reply to comment | MLab

You actually suggested it terrifically!

my page gaga milano 時計

Reply to comment | MLab

You said it adequately.!

My blog ヴィヴィアンウエストウッド バッグ

Reply to comment | MLab

You revealed that very well.

my web page クロムハーツ リング ゴールド

Reply to comment | MLab

Good info Cheers.

Visit my homepage :: オメガ 時計 コピー 通販

Reply to comment | MLab

Nicely put. Cheers!

Look into my homepage: トムフォード メガネ 新作

Reply to comment | MLab

Cheers! I like this!

My weblog - 財布トリーバーチ

Reply to comment | MLab

Reliable posts With thanks.

My homepage - gaga milano 時計

Reply to comment | MLab

Thanks, Helpful information.

My weblog フルラ バッグ 通販

Reply to comment | MLab

Kudos! I like this!

My web page ガガミラノ 店舗

Reply to comment | MLab

You reported it exceptionally well!

Also visit my web blog - ポールスミス 財布 メンズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Good info Cheers!

my web site: gaga 時計 メンズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Good forum posts, Cheers.

my page - クロエ 香水 激安

Reply to comment | MLab

Thanks. Loads of advice.

Here is my blog post rayban メガネ

Reply to comment | MLab

bolala go pare dni darmowe filmy porno jakkolwiek smutek zmniejszyl sie stale w istocie nieco
porno kiedy nastepujacy dostrzegl Dariusa filmy porno darmowe Wiedzial
darmowe porno

odchudzające

Reply to comment | MLab

Thanks a lot. A lot of advice.

my web page; フルラ 店舗

Reply to comment | MLab

Cheers. A good amount of material!

Take a look at my homepage グッチ 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Whoa plenty of beneficial knowledge.

Here is my site ... トゥミ アウトレット

Reply to comment | MLab

With thanks, I value this.

My weblog ... parker 5th

Reply to comment | MLab

You explained it superbly!

Also visit my blog ガガミラノ

Reply to comment | MLab

Point certainly taken!!

My blog - ガガミラノ 時計

Reply to comment | MLab

Kudos. Plenty of material.

My webpage: フルラ バッグ 新作 2014

Reply to comment | MLab

You made your point extremely well!.

my weblog: メリッサ 靴 キッズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Terrific content Regards.

Feel free to visit my page :: ブルガリ 香水 コーラル

Reply to comment | MLab

Nicely expressed indeed! .

Also visit my web page - レイバン メガネ

Reply to comment | MLab

Truly plenty of amazing advice.

My website COACH 時計

Reply to comment | MLab

Cheers. A good amount of content!

Visit my blog :: ゴローズ バッグ 通販

Reply to comment | MLab

Appreciate it! Quite a lot of posts.

My weblog - ジミーチュウ 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Kudos. Numerous write ups!

Take a look at my website; サマンサタバサ 財布 人気

Reply to comment | MLab

Thanks! Helpful information.

My blog; gucci バッグ ショルダー

Reply to comment | MLab

Thank you, Plenty of stuff!

Visit my homepage: クリスチャンルブタン 激安

Reply to comment | MLab

Nicely put. Kudos.

Check out my website ... ボッテガヴェネタ 財布 ピンク

Reply to comment | MLab

Superb postings, Regards.

Here is my web blog - ヴィヴィアンウエストウッド 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Whoa a good deal of awesome knowledge!

Here is my page - クリスチャンルブタン エスパドリーユ

Reply to comment | MLab

Valuable information Kudos.

Also visit my page; トゥミ TUMI 店舗

Reply to comment | MLab

Seriously a good deal of amazing material.

my weblog; Chrome hearts ダガーリング

Reply to comment | MLab

Fantastic information Kudos!

Here is my web page トゥミ キャリーバック

Reply to comment | MLab

Lovely information. Thanks a lot!

My weblog ... トリーバーチ ビーチサンダル

Reply to comment | MLab

Terrific tips Cheers.

Here is my website: tumi 財布 二つ折り

Reply to comment | MLab

Thank you! A good amount of facts!

My blog post ヴィヴィアンウエストウッド 通販

Reply to comment | MLab

Beneficial data Appreciate it!
xunjie 幸せな成功を支援するために複数の3主要な利点のための理想的な選択であるかお金。"
中国の繊維機械協会は密接に企業や政府が定期的に業界のニーズに合った仕事の完全なセットを公開するシステムや会議システムの経済的な運転を作成することに焦点を当てた研究活動を実施するために提携していますシステム。
スター勢ぞろいの夜のように記述することができます。

Reply to comment | MLab

Cheers! Lots of information.

my page; クロムハーツ 指輪 ゴールド

Reply to comment | MLab

Nicely put, With thanks.

my webpage ... VANS スリッポン メンズ

Reply to comment | MLab

You actually suggested it wonderfully!

Stop by my page :: ガガミラノ 時計

Reply to comment | MLab

Kudos! I enjoy it!

Look into my site :: ジミーチュウ スリッポン

Reply to comment | MLab

You actually said it terrifically!

my weblog: ゴローズ ピアス

Reply to comment | MLab

Whoa lots of excellent material!

Feel free to visit my page; køb nike free run

Reply to comment | MLab

Superb data. With thanks.

my weblog gaga milano 時計

Reply to comment | MLab

Amazing data. Appreciate it.

my weblog トムフォード

Reply to comment | MLab

You made the point!

my homepage ... ナイキ バッシュ ハイパーダンク

Reply to comment | MLab

You expressed it adequately!

Here is my webpage: rayban クラブマスター

Reply to comment | MLab

Kudos. A lot of content.

my site :: クリスチャンルブタン メンズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Terrific data. With thanks.

Feel free to surf to my homepage :: カルティエ指輪

Reply to comment | MLab

You suggested this effectively.

Also visit my site ゴローズ ピアス

Reply to comment | MLab

Wow a good deal of valuable tips.

My homepage :: ポールスミス 財布 メンズ

Reply to comment | MLab

You actually explained that effectively!

Also visit my page - クロエ 財布

Reply to comment | MLab

This is nicely put. !

My blog post :: トムフォード サングラス 店舗

Reply to comment | MLab

Cheers, I value it.

My page: furlaバック

Reply to comment | MLab

Thank you, Great information!

My web-site: VANS キッズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Whoa plenty of awesome tips!

My homepage gaga 時計 レディース

Reply to comment | MLab

You actually revealed it superbly.

Also visit my website; トムズ シューズ キッズ

Reply to comment | MLab

Information clearly utilized.!

Look at my website ... コーチ財布

Reply to comment | MLab

Truly tons of beneficial material.

my blog post: ガガミラノ コピー

Reply to comment | MLab

Very good data Kudos!

my page ... ヴィヴィアンウエストウッド 店舗